IN MEMORY OF THE SMOKY PUB

12. December 2011 16:35

I went to a dinner party the other night. Of course, I'd always rather be down the pub, but it was great fun and lively company nevertheless.

The curious thing about it, though – which would not have been so curious a few years ago – was that seven of the eight people around the table were serious smokers, smoking seriously.

The non-smoker was me. It's a role I've played on many occasions in the past, really ever since I started working on newspapers at the age of 19. I must have been the only hack I knew who didn't smoke. The office must have been in a constant fog. But it didn't bother me. I thought smokers were more interesting people.

It was the same down the pub. Smoking was a necessary part of drinking. Occasionally someone would remark, as we sat there with streaming eyes, that it was unusually smoky tonight, but there was nothing to be done about it.

Some mornings I woke up with a smoke hangover, usually confusingly mingled with a drink hangover but sometimes, when I knew I hadn't had that much to drink, on its own. My clothes, too, reeked of stale smoke which, in Proustian moments, took me back to my grandmother's coats. She was always in the pub and they always smelled of smoke, even though she was a non-smoker.

I had that a bit after the dinner party. A second-hand smoker's cough and a jumper I chucked straight in the washing machine. Nothing too terrible. But it reminded me that I'm personally quite pleased about the smoking ban.

Professionally I've been more ambivalent. It's got nothing to do with ‘individual freedom'. That, in my view, is a nonsensical notion. We are social beings to the root. In what sense can we behave as individuals? But I worried for the old boys who went to the pub for a bit of warmth and society, and the enjoyment of a fag with their half of mild.

I supported the idea that pubs might, by installing efficient ventilation and air-cleaning kit, ‘remove the smoke – not the smoker' as the slogan went. But over a number of years, as the pub trade fought a rearguard action against legislation, it became clear to me that the world was changing and that people – smokers and non-smokers alike – were ready for a ban.

And so it's proved. The smoking ban, it's true, was the last nail in the coffin for some pubs but the vast majority, and their customers, have adapted to the new circumstances.

Has it made pubs better places? I'm afraid you have to say it has.

Tags:

Comments (2) -

12/12/2011 8:05:14 PM #

Dave Atherton

Phil,  I have adjusted (I go down the pub less) I will NEVER accept the ban. The answer then has to be smoker only pubs, then if you do not like it you do not have to go there. Here from the BBPA pub closures pre and post ban. The last column is the number of pubs closing a week. Yes people have got used to the ban they drink and smoke at home.

2003  59,400  -1.16%  9,600  1,200  13
2004  59,000  -0.67%  10,000  1,600  8
2005  58,600  -0.68%  10,400  2,000  8
2006  58,200  -0.68%  10,800  2,400  8
2007  56,791  -2.42%  12,209  3,809  27
2008  54,818  -3.47%  14,182  5,782  38
2009  53,466  -2.47%  15,534  7,134  26
2010  52,000  -2.74%  17,000  8,600  28

docs.google.com/.../ccc

Dave Atherton United Kingdom | Reply

12/12/2011 8:15:34 PM #

Dave Atherton

Phil people are quick to blame the recession but having  researched GDP figures for 2006-10 it was not until the 2nd quarter of 2008 and not by much -0.3% did we start to go into recession.


2006       1.1  0.3  0.5  0.8            = 2.7%      closures of 200 pubs

2007       1.0  0.6  0.5  0.3            = 2.4%     closures of 1,409 pubs

2008       0.5  -0.3  -0.9  -2.1

2009      -2.2 -0.8  -0.3  -0.5

2010       0.2   1.1  0.7   -0.5



daveatherton.wordpress.com/.../

Dave Atherton United Kingdom | Reply

Add comment




  Country flag
biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading


About the author

Phil Mellows

Phil Mellows is a freelance journalist and writer specialising in the UK pub industry and alcohol policy. For more information, and the Politics of Drinking blog, go to www.philmellows.com
You can also follow Phil on Twitter at www.twitter.com/philmellows

Month List